High Power Heat Pipe Dense Fin Heat Sink

Our company's mission is to wholeheartedly produce the best, distinctive, market-oriented and competitive Ultra Thin Vapor Chamber Heatsink, Skived Fin Heat Sink, AL Extrusion Heat Sink. Our company's enterprise spirit is people-oriented, win by quality, based on domestic, expand international. We're confident that we are going to share mutual results and build solid co-operation relations with our companions in this market. We are adhering to the tenet of 'taking science and technology as the guide and quality as the center'. Warmly welcome friends from all walks of life to visit our factory for inspection and guidance.

Heat pipe vs Vapor chamber

When dealing with heat dissipation projects for high-power electronic devices such as CPUs, GPUs, ASICs, or IGBT modules, we are often asked the same question: Should we use heat pipes or vapor chamber? Which of them is better?

There is no standard answer to this question. Both utilize the principle of phase change heat transfer and have very high thermal conductivity, but their roles in heat dissipation schemes are actually very different.

This article mainly shares some of our team's experiences in practical projects, hoping to help you clarify when to use which solution.

Working principle

vapor chamber is responsible for "diffusion" and heat pipes is responsible for "transmission"

If we imagine heat as water flow:

The vapor chamber is like a flat "water pan" - heat comes in from a point source in the middle and quickly spreads across the entire surface, "diluting" the heat at high temperature points.

A heat pipe is like a "water pipe" - it quickly transports heat from point A to point B in the distance, making it suitable for scenarios that require "transfer".

So, which one to choose first depends on whether your heat needs to be 'spread out' or 'sent away'.

Heat treatment method

Vapor chamber: It evenly spreads heat from the surface of the chip to a large area of the bottom plate or fins. Suitable for situations with high power but limited space and insufficient heat dissipation area.

Heat pipe: Heat pipes are used to connect heat sources to distal fins, especially for relatively tortuous paths. Even if the path is straight, more heat pipes will be used instead of VC to remotely transfer heat. This is the key difference between heat pipes and VC radiators, as heat pipes focus on heat transfer.

Applicable power density

Vapor chamber: It is usually ideal to handle heat flux densities above 20W/cm ². We have done cases with heat flux densities above 300W/cm ² and can still effectively control the temperature.

Heat pipe: A single heat pipe can handle tens to hundreds of watts, but if the heat source area is large, multiple pipes often need to be used side by side.

Thickness limit

Temperature equalizing plate: The common sintered core VC thickness is between 2.5 and 4 millimeters, and ultra-thin versions can be made thinner, but the process and cost will increase.

Heat pipe: The diameter of the round pipe is generally 3 to 6 millimeters, and it can be flattened to about 2 millimeters, but the heat transfer capacity will be reduced after flattening.

Handling of multiple heat sources

Vapor chamber: If multiple heating chips are in close proximity, a single VC can cover them simultaneously, achieving overall temperature equalization.

Heat pipe: If the heat sources are dispersed, usually each heat source is individually arranged or multiple heat pipes are connected to the same set of heat dissipation fins.

Cost

Vapor chamber: The larger the size, the higher the cost, especially for large areas of VC exceeding 100 × 100mm, and the processing yield will affect the unit price.

Heat pipe: The cost of standard specification heat pipes is relatively controllable, and customized bending or flattening may increase some costs, but overall it is still cheaper than VC of the same area.

You may have encountered several practical pitfalls in design as well

1. The area of the vapor chamber must be large enough

Some customers want to use a VC that is about the same size as the chip to directly attach it to the chip, and then add a fan to blow it on top. The effect of doing so is actually not much different from that of copper blocks. The area of VC should be equal to or greater than 10 times the area of the heat source.

2. The bends of the heat pipe should be minimized as much as possible

Heat pipes can be bent, but with each bend, their heat transfer capacity decreases slightly. If there are multiple bends on the path, the actual heat dissipation effect may only be half or even lower than that of a straight pipe. So try to be as straight as possible. If bending is necessary, the corners should be rounded and the radius of the bend should not be too small.

3. Two technologies can be used together

For some particularly high-power cases, we will combine VC with heat pipes: use VC to directly contact the chip, quickly spread the heat throughout the entire substrate, and then further guide the heat to the large-area fins at the far end through several heat pipes. This combination scheme is common on many server CPU heat sinks.

how should I choose vapor chamber or heat pipe?

If I were to give a simple direction for judgment:

Priority should be given to the case of vapro chamber:

The chip has a high power density (such as 20W/cm ² or more)

Space height is limited, requiring a slim design (3-5mm height)

The chip area is not large, but we hope to quickly spread the heat to the large-area heat sink

I hope the surface temperature of the entire radiator is more uniform and reduces local hotspots

Prioritize the case of heat pipes:

There is a certain distance (such as 50mm or more) between the heat source and the final heat dissipation position

Multiple heat sources distributed in different locations

Cost control is relatively strict

It is acceptable to embed the heat pipe into the aluminum base plate and heat it evenly before transferring heat through the base plate

The combination of the two:

High power density and the need to guide heat to distant locations for heat dissipation

The internal space of the system is irregular, and the heat dissipation path needs to bypass other components

Pursuing ultimate performance with relatively sufficient budget

AWIND often designs such integrated solutions for the following areas:

High end servers

telecommunication base station

Industrial power converter

If you have any ideas in this regard, please feel free to contact us for more information, and we can evaluate your project at any time.

We are dedicated to provide high-quality services to users at home and abroad to meet the new demand for High Power Heat Pipe Dense Fin Heat Sink. Talent is a strategic resource for the harmonious and sustainable development of an enterprise. We encourage our employees to be sober and clear about their responsibilities at work, to fulfill their duties, to play and explore their abilities and potentials, then work proactively, produce good results, enjoy the fun of work and enjoy the joy of achieving results.